Discussion Forums

re: Order Cancel Request
Andrew Schorr
6 Feb 1998 1:56PM ET

Vitaliy wrote:

> You are correct. However according to 4.1 that is the only way to make *any* changes to an order, including reducing the share quantity.

How do you justify that statement? On page 33 of the 4.1 draft,
it says that "It is recommended that the Cancel/Replace Request
message be used to partially cancel (reduce) an order..."
Note: it says "recommended," not "mandated."
I am particularly talking (in this thread) about the case
where a reduction in quantity is implemented using an Order Cancel Request.
Please refer to the subject of this thread in case you have
any doubts on that point.

Andrew Schorr
Daiwa Securities America Inc.
schorr@ead.dsa.com

P.S. I know that some FIX folks do not like the concept of
partially cancelling an order, but this has been used for
decades in SIAC's CMS system (aka superDOT), and it is ridiculous
to contemplate developing a new protocol that does not support
that functionality!


Order Cancel Request
Ryan Pierce / Townsend Analytics Ltd. / Archipelago LLC   30 Jan 1998 12:44PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Scott Atwell / American Century   30 Jan 1998 7:24PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Andrew Schorr   5 Feb 1998 2:10PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
John Armstrong   6 Feb 1998 7:45AM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Andrew Schorr   6 Feb 1998 10:11AM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Vitaliy Kantor   6 Feb 1998 1:26PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Andrew Schorr   6 Feb 1998 1:56PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
John Armstrong   6 Feb 1998 2:25PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Andrew Schorr   6 Feb 1998 2:57PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Jem Day - BGI   6 Feb 1998 3:16PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Andrew Schorr   24 Feb 1998 10:40AM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
daconner@pwj.com   24 Feb 1998 3:07PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Vitaliy Kantor   24 Feb 1998 3:48PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Anonymous   24 Feb 1998 4:06PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Ed Colletta   25 Feb 1998 2:12PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Ryan Pierce / Townsend Analytics Ltd. / Archipelago LLC   24 Feb 1998 5:03PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
John Armstrong   24 Feb 1998 7:21PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
daconner@pwj.com   24 Feb 1998 3:08PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Jem.Day@bglobal.com   24 Feb 1998 3:36PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
jdamon@capis.com   24 Feb 1998 5:56PM ET
Cancel Reduce Scenarios w/ FIX 4.1
johna@ms.com   26 Feb 1998 3:38PM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Chris Morstatt   2 Mar 1998 9:05AM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Andrew Schorr   25 Feb 1998 10:13AM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
johna@ms.com   25 Feb 1998 10:43AM ET
re: Order Cancel Request
Andrew Schorr   26 Feb 1998 9:20AM ET
Cancel Reduce Scenarios w/ FIX 4.1
johna@ms.com   26 Feb 1998 6:56PM ET